Layer Composition in Bezae

The items in the clusters represent individual readings of Bezae in John 4:1-42. With six clusters, PAM produces clusters with the compositions below.

Explanation of Columns
Verse: chapter and verse reference in John.
Reading: the text form found in Bezae.
Witnesses: selected early Christian writers and manuscripts that support Bezae’s reading. (Because we are partitioning Bezae’s readings by layer, readings not attested in Bezae at each variation unit are not included in the clusters.)
Fit: an indicator of how representative the reading is of its cluster. Higher values indicate a more central position in the cluster. This value is obtained from the “sil_width” column returned from the sil() function in R’s “cluster” package.
Level: the level of the reading in the local genealogical stemma based on internal criteria. While the use of internal criteria is inherently subjective to a degree, the hope is that clear cases will outnumber ambiguous cases and provide a sense as to whether the layer could represent a specific historical influence that can be sequenced in relation to other layers.

Cluster 1

Verse Reading Witnesses    Fit Level
4:36 και Ir S Θ Ω 0141 13 35 579 821 1128 1242 1293 1654 2561 2786 a b d ff c    0.3337         2
4:21 γυναι πιστευε μοι Θ Ω 1 13 33 35 565 579 1010 1128 1242 1654 2561 e d r ff c    0.2726         2
4:17 και ειπεν Or L Θ Ω 0141 1 13 35 213 397 565 579 821 1010 1128 1293 1654 2786 d c    0.2559         2
4:15 ερχωμαι C 0141 1 35 213 397 565 579 597 821 1293 1654 2786 e a b d q r ff c    0.2452         3
4:30 om. (ουν, δε) P75 B C L W Θ Ω 0141 33 35 213 397 579 821 2786 a b d c    0.2016         1
4:31 οι μαθηται Or P66.75 S B C L W 1 13 397 565 579 597 892 1010 1241 1293 a b d r ff c    0.0668         1
4:1 ιησους P66 S Θ 1 35 565 1010 1241 1293 e a b d r ff c    -0.0142         2
4:14 εγω Hil S 33 213 397 1010 1071 1241 1242 1293 2561 a b d    -0.032         2

Cluster 2

Verse Reading Witnesses    Fit Level
4:3 om. (δε, ουν) Or P66.75 S B C L W Θ Ω 0141 13 33 35 213 397 565 579 597 821 892 1010 1071 1241 1242 1293 1654 2561 2786 e a d q r ff c    0.7218         1
4:35 ιδου λεγω υμιν Or Ir Hil P66.75 S B C L W Θ Ω 0141 1 13 33 35 213 397 579 597 821 892 1010 1071 1128 1242 1293 1654 2561 2786 e a b d q r ff c    0.7182         1
4:12 και αυτος Or P66.75 B C L W Ω 0141 1 13 33 35 213 397 565 579 597 821 892 1010 1071 1128 1241 1242 1293 1654 2561 2786 a b d q r ff c    0.7173         1
4:12 ος Or P66.75 B C L W Ω 0141 1 13 33 35 213 397 565 579 597 821 892 1010 1071 1128 1241 1242 1293 1654 2561 2786 e a b d q r ff c    0.716         1
4:14 εν αυτω πηγη P75 S B C L W Θ Ω 0141 1 13 33 35 213 397 565 579 597 821 892 1010 1071 1128 1241 1242 1293 1654 2561 2786 e a b d q r ff c    0.7143         1
4:6 πηγη Or Te P75 S B C L W Θ Ω 0141 1 13 33 35 213 397 565 579 597 821 892 1010 1071 1128 1242 1293 1654 2561 2786 e a b d q r ff c    0.7133         1
4:10 ει Or P75 S B C L W Θ Ω 0141 1 13 33 35 397 565 579 597 821 892 1010 1128 1241 1242 1293 1654 2561 2786 e a b d q r ff c    0.7101         1
4:37 εν γαρ … ο θεριζων Or Ir P66 S B C L Θ Ω 0141 1 13 33 35 213 397 565 579 597 821 892 1010 1071 1128 1241 1242 1293 1654 2561 2786 e a b d q r ff c    0.7076         1
4:2 καιτοιγε Or P66.75 S B L W Θ Ω 0141 1 13 33 35 213 565 579 597 821 892 1010 1071 1128 1241 1242 1293 1654 2561 2786 e a b q ff c    0.7007         1
4:5 om. (ουν … σαμαρειας) Or P66 S B C L Θ Ω 0141 1 13 33 35 213 397 565 579 597 821 892 1010 1071 1128 1241 1242 1293 1654 2561 2786 e a b d q ff c    0.6984         1
4:7 om. (τις, ουν) P66.75 B C L W Θ Ω 0141 1 13 33 35 213 397 565 579 597 821 892 1010 1071 1241 1242 1293 1654 2561 2786 e a d q ff c    0.6981         1
4:11 η γυνη Or P66 C L Θ Ω 0141 1 13 33 35 213 397 565 579 597 821 892 1010 1071 1128 1241 1242 1293 1654 2561 2786 e a b d q r ff c    0.6919         2
4:39 εις αυτον των σαμαριτων Or P66.75 B C L W Θ Ω 0141 13 33 35 213 397 579 597 821 892 1010 1071 1128 1241 1242 1293 1654 2561 2786 b d q r ff c    0.6902         1
4:42 οτι P66.75 S C L W Θ Ω 0141 1 13 33 35 213 397 565 579 597 821 892 1010 1071 1241 1242 1293 1654 2561 2786 e a d q ff c    0.6901         1
4:27 ελαλει Or P66.75 S B C L W Ω 0141 1 13 33 35 213 397 565 597 821 892 1010 1071 1128 1241 1242 1293 1654 2561 2786 e d q ff c    0.6887         1
4:21 οτε Or Hil P66.75 S B C L W Ω 0141 1 13 33 35 213 397 565 597 821 1010 1071 1128 1241 1242 1293 1654 2561 2786 e a b d q r    0.6867         1
4:23 αυτον Or Hil P75 B C L W Θ Ω 0141 13 33 35 213 397 565 579 597 821 892 1010 1128 1241 1242 1293 2561 2786 a b d q r ff c    0.6769         1
4:14 ου διψησει … δωσω αυτω Or P66.75 S B L W Θ Ω 1 33 35 213 397 565 579 597 892 1010 1071 1128 1241 1242 1293 2561 2786 e a b d q r ff c    0.6596         1
4:37 τουτω Or Ir P66 S B C L Ω 0141 1 33 35 213 397 565 597 821 892 1010 1241 1242 1293 1654 2561 2786 e a b d q r ff c    0.6407         1
4:27 εθαυμαζον Or P66.75 S B C L W Θ 0141 1 33 213 397 565 579 597 821 892 1010 1242 1293 1654 2561 2786 e a b d q r ff c    0.6391         2
4:9 ουν P66.75 B C L W Θ Ω 0141 13 33 35 213 397 597 821 1071 1128 1241 1242 1293 1654 2561 2786 e a b d q r ff c    0.6263         1
4:1 η Or P66.75 S C W Θ Ω 0141 1 13 33 35 213 565 597 821 1010 1241 1242 1293 1654 2561 2786 e a b d q r ff c    0.6238         2
4:41 πλειους Or Ir P66 S B C L Ω 0141 1 13 33 35 213 397 565 579 597 821 892 1010 1071 1128 1241 1242 1293 1654 2561 2786 b d ff c    0.6209         1
4:42 οτι ουτος εστιν αληθως Or P75 B C L W Θ Ω 0141 1 13 33 35 213 397 565 821 892 1010 1071 1128 1242 1293 1654 2561 2786 a b d q c    0.6048         1
4:30 εξηλθον Or P66.75 S B C W Θ Ω 0141 1 13 33 35 565 579 821 892 1010 1128 1242 1293 1654 2561 2786 a b d q r ff c    0.5912         1
4:10 αυτον Or P66.75 S B C L W Θ Ω 0141 1 13 33 35 213 397 565 579 597 821 892 1010 1071 1241 1293 1654 2561 2786 e b r    0.5866         1
4:41 om. (εις αυτον) Or P66.75 S B C L W Ω 0141 1 33 35 213 397 565 579 597 821 1242 1654 2561 2786 e a b d q r ff c    0.573         1
4:21 προσκυνησετε Or Hil P66.75 S B C L W Θ Ω 0141 33 35 213 397 597 821 892 1241 1242 1654 2561 2786 e a b d q r ff c    0.5603         1
4:3 παλιν P66.75 S C L W Θ 1 13 33 213 397 565 597 892 1010 1071 1128 1241 1242 1293 1654 2561 2786 e a b d ff c    0.4772         2
4:42 ο χριστος C L Θ Ω 0141 1 13 33 35 213 397 565 579 597 821 892 1010 1071 1128 1241 1242 1293 1654 2561 2786 e d q    0.3772         2
4:25 οιδα Or Hil P66.75 S B C W Θ Ω 0141 1 35 565 579 821 892 1010 1242 1293 1654 e a b d q r ff c    0.2777         1
4:16 τον ανδρα σου P66.75 S C L W Θ Ω 0141 1 13 33 35 213 397 565 579 597 821 892 1071 1128 1241 1242 1654 2561 2786    0.2408         2
4:34 ποιησω Or Te Cy P66.75 B C L W Θ 0141 1 33 565 579 597 821 1010 1128 1293 2561 e a b d q r ff c    0.2263         1

Cluster 3

Verse Reading Witnesses    Fit Level
4:15 διψησω P66    0.2143         2
4:42 τη δε γυναικι ελεγον Or P66 2786 d    0.2105         2
4:33 εν εαυτοις / προς αλληλους οι μαθηται 13    0.2002         3
4:38 om. (ο, ου) Or L e d    0.1329         2
4:2 αυτος ιησους 33 579 597 1241 d ff    0.1259         2
4:35 om. (ετι) Or P75 L W Ω 13 35 1241 1654 d    -0.032         2
4:17 ανδρα ουκ εχω S C L 597 1241 2786 d r    -0.0641         2
4:29 εκεινος d q    -0.079         2
4:42 αυτου γαρ ακηκοαμεν a d    -0.1226         2

Cluster 4

Verse Reading Witnesses    Fit Level
4:35 ηδη Or P66.75 S B C L W 33 821 e b d q r    0.2706         1
4:9 πειν αιτεις P75 S B C L W a b d q r ff c    0.2145         1
4:31 om. (δε) P66 B C L 2786 e a d r c    0.1914         1
4:20 προσκυνειν δει Or Hil P66.75 S B C L W 33 892 1010 2786 b d q ff c    0.0797         1
4:3 την ιουδαιαν γην Θ 1 13 565 1242 2561 e b r ff    0.0237         2

Cluster 5

Verse Reading Witnesses    Fit Level
4:9 συ ιουδαιος ων πως 1654 e a b d r ff    0.5139         2
4:19 om. (συ) Hil 1654 e a b d r ff    0.5139         2
4:11 υδωρ ζων e a b d q r ff c    0.4882         2
4:14 ου διψησει Cy e a b d q r ff c    0.4882         2
4:27 αυτω S 1654 a b d r ff    0.3412         2
4:17 εχεις S e b d r ff c    0.3389         2
4:21 τουτω τω ορει Hil e a b d r    0.2658         2
4:14 ος δε πινων Cy S a b d ff c    0.2031         2

Cluster 6

Verse Reading Witnesses    Fit Level
4:27 εν τουτω S d r    0.3031         2
4:37 εστιν ο λογος b d q    0.1943         2
4:42 σην μαρτυριαν S b d r    0.1779         3
4:24 om. (αυτον) S d ff    0.1688         2
4:30 και C b d r    0.1613         2
4:24 προσκυνειν δει Hil S a d r    0.1613         2
4:11 om. (ουν) S q r c    0.1471         2
4:33 δε a b q r    0.0731         2
4:28 η γυνη την υδριαν εαυτης b d q r ff    -0.1139         2
4:9 om. (ου γαρ συγ. ιουδ. σαμαρ.) S e a b d    -0.1796         2